A Textbook Problem
Posted: Fri Dec 10, 2010 11:08 am
A TextBook Probability Problem:: there're $40$ students in a class among whom $20$ students play football, $25$ students play cricket and $10$ play both. if one is selected who plays football, then determine probability of his playing cricket.
so first i solved it in that way:: among $20$ students who play football, there're $10$ who play cricket also... then the answer is $\frac{10}{20}$ = $\frac{1}{2}$
then i found another solution:: there're total $35$ students who play at least one games, so probability of his playing football is $\frac{20}{35}$ and probability of his playing cricket is $\frac{25}{35}$ , then the answer is $\frac{20}{35}\cdot\frac{25}{35}$ = $\frac{20}{49}$
which one is wrong and why?
so first i solved it in that way:: among $20$ students who play football, there're $10$ who play cricket also... then the answer is $\frac{10}{20}$ = $\frac{1}{2}$
then i found another solution:: there're total $35$ students who play at least one games, so probability of his playing football is $\frac{20}{35}$ and probability of his playing cricket is $\frac{25}{35}$ , then the answer is $\frac{20}{35}\cdot\frac{25}{35}$ = $\frac{20}{49}$
which one is wrong and why?